Good Cooking..."A Mouthwatering Site on the Internet" since 1995
Antique Walnut & Pewter Fork circ. 1880 Bohemia
by Chef John J. Vyhnanek
How do you buy a steak?
I counted 60 different types of beef cattle breeds listed at http://www.cattletoday.com
Cattle Today Online is the cattleman's guide to the cattle
business. One well known independent
ranch, Niman Ranch, raises Angus, Hereford and Short Horn, three of the 60 different
cattle breeds. Angus, Hereford and Short Horn
cattle are the most popular cattle to raise from a rancher's
standpoint and are considered to be a better return on the
rancher's dollar when they are sold. The meat of these
three cattle is also considered to taste very good. One might wonder
what the difference is between all the breeds and why Niman Ranch's beef
is considered to be special: is it all in the marketing? What is
the difference in the beef you buy at a steakhouse such as Peter Luger's in
Brooklyn, NY (considered by many to be the best steak in
America) and the beef you might buy in a supermarket in West Palm Beach,
FL or from Niman Ranch for that fact? Not much,
from a United States Department of Agriculture grading
standpoint. Under very strict guidelines, beef graded prime is
the best you can buy. Other factors enter the grading
picture, such as weight, fat thickness and hardness of the meat
and fat. Prime graded beef is what the best steakhouses
and restaurants usually buy, it is an ultra premium product.
Restaurants like Peter Luger's may enhance the meat's tenderness
and flavor through aging. Simply put prime beef is a sought after commodity. Other
grades of meat in the United States include choice and select,
to mention a few. The following is my explanation of the subject---
Farmers raise and sell cattle of any of the 60 cattle
breeds. It is sold at auction as lots to the highest
bidder. It's processed and it is graded by the USDA.
Before a distributor gets it for distribution, selected lots are
hand picked and depending on who buys it and for what reason, some lots are much
better than others. If a buyer represents a
steakhouse like Peter Luger's, the buyer is focusing in on
a specific grade---Prime, a specific yield grade (fat to meat
ratio) and cattle type. The buyer is willing to pay a premium
for the lot of beef loins as are other bidders from other companies
like Morton's Steakhouse, the Palm or any number of high-end
distributors who specialize in prime beef. The competition
is stiff for this small amount of beef and that is one reason
the prices are so high.
Aside from this
ultra-competitive purchasing circle, we also have high quality
meat purveyors competing for the remaining prime and top range of the
choice graded beef. The remaining "next best" beef
goes to supermarkets, they want their
share too! They usually purchase from the middle of the Choice
grade. Some supermarkets don't want the Choice beef
either! The profit margins aren't as good, so many markets
purchase the third best called the Select grade. If you
noticed the pictures of the meat below you will see the Select
grade is much leaner than the Prime or Choice, it is still wholesome and good, but it won't be as tender,
flavorful and juicy as the 2 other grades. On the other
hand, if you are using it for pot roast or stew, you probably
won't notice the difference!If you want to learn
more about the subject, search the Internet using the keywords,
"prime beef", "beef grading" or
"raising beef cattle".
Top 3 United States Department of Agriculture Meat Grade
The best grade of beef is USDA Prime.
This grade is
earmarked for the finest cuts that conform
to the complex grading formula that the USDA applies to the
inspection of beef. It comprises less than 2% of all graded
It has an abundant amount of marbling (the network of fine
lines of white fat). This marbling, as well as other factors
such as feed quality, and aging, adds to the rich flavor and
fine texture of the best cuts.
Prime beef tends to be found only in restaurants, fine
butcher shops, and custom or specialty suppliers of beef.
USDA Choice is the next best grade of beef.
Choice can be nearly as good as Prime, especially in the
top 2/3 of the grade. Generally, it tends to have a little
less marbling (and therefore less complexity to the flavor)
and a slightly tougher texture than Prime.
Choice is usually the highest grade found in grocery store
meat departments, although some chains may custom order
prime cuts for large purchases.
USDA Select is the next grade of beef.
This grade can be nearly as good as Choice grade (in the
top 1/3 of the grade). Select has less marbling than Choice,
and will have even less complexity to the flavor.
Select can be somewhat more tough in texture.
Select can dry out easily when overcooked, especially as
It is the most common grade of beef available to, and
bought by, most people.
Now the crazy thing: this is why the meat is federally
inspected and graded---to assure consistency within the grading
process. Let's say a rancher sells 100 head of cattle, it is inspected, graded and processed---12 are graded Prime, 35
Choice, 40 Select, 10 Standard and 3 Commercial. The 12
Prime are swooped up as well as most of the Choice, by buyers
representing steakhouses and meat packers; supermarkets take the
remaining Choice and Select pieces. What is left goes into the
ground beef market and is processed as hamburger patties and is
sold and distributed world wide to anyone from Burger King to
Wendy's and from Wal-Mart to Costco. This is what you get when you buy the 5 pound box of 1/4 pound
frozen hamburger patties from any of the aforementioned stores. Remember---it's
good and it's wholesome, but
it's not good enough to be a steak. More confusion: the lower
graded cattle may be from the best breeds of beef cattle.
Where do you buy a good or even great steak? First you
should know that it
will cost you more money for a steak this year than last year, and this
will be a continuing trend. Beef prices are up world wide
because of demand, fear of mad cow, and the Atkins high protein
diet. Supply simply can't keep up with demand anymore.
Some supermarkets, including Whole Foods, have systems in place so that the beef they buy meets
certain specifications of quality. In fact most
restaurants have specifications they give to their meat
suppliers that detail the quality level they are looking
for. Without this "Specification Sheet" there
would be no consistency in what was received from week to week.
As a consumer, you will have to trust your butcher and hope they
are buying better than average beef. Ask questions and become
educated so you know a little about what you are
buying. I've had as many great steaks from the former
New York City, as I have had from a supermarket called Stop and
Shop. I knew what I was looking for; what cut of steak,
of the meat, marbling, grade, size of the steak in roundness.
Balducci's sold Prime sirloin strip steaks at 16.95 a pound and Stop and
Shop sold Choice Sirloin strip steaks at 6.99. The Stop and Shop
was almost as good! Was it worth the price difference? To
some it is!
steak is what you will find in most supermarkets in the
USA. It's Choice grade and called a Sirloin Strip or
Boneless Top Loin Steak. After opening the package it will
require a little additional trimming before cooking.
steak is what you might get from a butcher shop in the
USA. It's Certified Angus Beef
Sirloin Strip or Boneless Top Loin Steak. It's trimmed well and
ready for cooking. Read about Certified Angus Beef
Certified Angus Beef and
other brands like it.
Back in 1978 a beef program was formed between
the American Angus Association and beef produces, packers and
distributors. The goal was to provide assurances of a
certain level of quality and flavor for consumers. The
result was Certified Angus Beef or CAB for short. CAB states
that less than 8 percent of beef produced in the USA can earn
the distinctive Certified Angus Beef brand
stamp. I can attest to the consistent quality of the brand and
often seek it out for my personal consumption. This
registered name is sometimes misused by those who want
to confuse you and make a quick buck with lesser quality beef.
Most copy-cats claim either Certified Beef, Black Angus Beef,
Angus Beef and or any combination of words, label design and or
color. It's like buying Kellogg's Special K and getting a
generic brand because you thought it was Kellogg's since the label
and color of the box looked the same. Because of the CAB
success other meat companies have developed similar lines and
claims. The following are examples of just 2 other premium
products, they are Sterling Silver Premium Meats/ Cargill Excel
and Premium Gold Angus brand.
Here are 4 top quality wholesalers in the
T F Kinnealey & Co 1100 Pearl Street
Brockton, MA 02301 (508) 638-4700
Stock Yards Packing 2457 W North Ave. Melrose Park, IL
60160 (877) 785-9273
Allen Brothers, Inc. 3737 South Halsted Street Chicago,
Illinois 60609-1689 (800) 548-7777
Atlanta 2194 Marietta Boulevard, NW Atlanta, GA 30318
What is Wagyu or Kobe beef?
Wagyu is a breed of cattle naturally predisposed to producing densely marbled beef. In fact, Wagyu beef surpasses USDA marbling standards for prime-grade beef. Often referred to as the "foie gras of beef," Wagyu has an exquisitely tender texture and an incomparably rich taste.
You may already be familiar with the famed Japanese Kobe beef which is a special grade of beef from cattle raised in Kobe, Japan. These cattle are massaged with sake and are fed a daily diet that includes large amounts of beer. This produces meat that is extraordinarily tender, finely marbled, and full-flavored. It is also extremely expensive, often costing more than $100 per pound.. Wagyu is the same breed stock that yields Kobe beef. To earn the appellation of Kobe beef its production must conform to standards imposed within that region.
What is marbling?
According to the Arizona Barbeque Association---
Marbling is the fine specks of fat within the meat of the beef. While studies show that marbling does not significantly increase the caloric count of beef, without question, it greatly enhances flavor and tenderness.
of these steaks are of the Choice grade even though there is a noticeable
color difference in the meat. The color difference can be
due to several different factors. Perhaps a different
breed of cattle, exposure to air and oxidation after cutting,
the redder one may have been dry aged and the lighter one wet
aged. What was the diet, how much grass and or grain
may have been a factor. After cooking, they were both
What is aging, wet or dry?
Aging is a natural process that improves the
palatability of cuts of meat, especially the rib and loin. To
learn more about the process, here is an in-depth article from
Iowa State University, Department of Animal Science on
Seasoning a steak before grilling: I rub the steak with
a neutral oil such as canola, corn or vegetable. I have
even used clarified butter and plain olive oil, however I never
use extra virgin olive, walnut, roasted peanut or sesame oil
because these oils would give the meat an unnatural taste.
This oil rub lubricates the meats and the grill's surface so the meat
doesn't stick to the grill and tear when turned. I lightly
salt and pepper the steak as well, usually with a blend of
Diamond Crystal Kosher salt and ground white pepper. This is a very basic
seasoning that eliminates blandness so when a customer at a
restaurant takes his first bite it tastes good. As I
said above, lightly salt and pepper---you can always add more at
the table. I don't rub the steak with crushed peppercorns,
chopped rosemary, garlic, sage or anything else for that fact,
because it can burn and turn to ashes and impart a
The appearance of the steak is very important too! When
first put on the grill the steak should be in the
shape it was when it was first prepared. In other words,
it shouldn't be flattened by pounding it with the palm of your
hand or other device. The steak should be even in thickness from
one end to the other so it will cook uniformly. The best
way to achieve a good looking steak as opposed to one that looks
like a truck ran over it is to cup your hands and push inwards
while holding your hands around the edges of the steak.
This will plump the meat and return it to its original
shape. It is now ready for grilling.
What type of grill?
Whatever the type of grill you use, it must be very hot in
one area, then have areas of less intense heat in other
Usually when the steak is a bit more than half done it should
be turned. You can actually see the cooking process on the
sides of the meat as it cooks, first the surface area cooks;
then the cooking creeps up toward the center. In your mind you need
to realize the doneness you want and turn the steak over so you
will have the steak cook evenly on the second side as
well. It's practice, practice, practice or use this basic
rule of thumb---for a 1 inch thick steak grilled over
medium-high heat it will require 2 minutes per side for rare, 3
minutes per side for medium-rare and 4 minutes per side for
medium to medium-well.
See what different
doneness looks like---
How to eat a steak?
I like my steak cooked medium-rare with salt , fresh ground black pepper, a
little melted butter and fresh chopped parsley or chives. The key
ingredient to my enjoyment is a very sharp knife. I can't
stand restaurants that buy great meat and only present you with
a cheap serrated knife that couldn't cut butter---it defeats
the purpose of Prime meat and makes it seem inferior to what it
One of the best parts of a steak meal is the
juices that are left for dunking bread in. I prefer a
crispy loaf of French bread because it doesn't compete with the
flavor of the steak and its juices. I must confess that I
also like a light caraway rye bread spread with a little
I don't do steak sauce on a really good steak, but on a
London Broil or Flank steak I'll enjoy Pickapeppa, a Jamaican
Steak Sauce, or Worcestershire and A-1 too.